The Bobcat Nation

"The 6-foot-5 Swogger has a strong arm and marginal mobility"

"Marginal mobility." Merry Christmas Clive Lowe and Bobby Daly.

Thank God it's over.

So did he actually choose the Griz or were they his only choice left? I would imagine that other schools would get tired of courting this princess just like the 'Cats did.

A guy with his poor speed and deteriorating legs ought to make a nice, big, fat target for King, Daly, Lowe and Co... If he isn't retired by then.

duelalumnicat wrote:"The 6-foot-5 Swogger has a strong arm and marginal mobility"

"Marginal mobility." Merry Christmas Clive Lowe and Bobby Daly.

I think Epi King will enjoy this as well. He sounds pretty cocky for never doing anything at the DI-A level. But, then again, how hard is it to complete a shovel pass?

Heheh

I guess we agree that the Griz signing this guy will greatly benifit our blitzing LB's.

GavinDonos wrote:Heheh

I guess we agree that the Griz signing this guy will greatly benifit our blitzing LB's.

And Baby Hauck has already named him the spring drill starter. Gotta love that if your Berquist or Washington I hope he starts for them, is a bust and they burn another year of Berquist's/Washington/Stapp's eligibility

Good for the Griz. I honestly think it is a good pick up for them.

I hope he enjoys his time at UM, and does well in the classroom and in the community.

Beating the griz again next year just got that much sweeter! Thank you Mr Arrogance.

I liked the part of the article that he mentions that he has been told he will be the starter going into the spring session. Kramer probably told him he could fight for the position and he didn't want to hear that.

In no way am I saying "geez the Cats didn't want him anyway", but I a personally am glad that he went to the griz.

GavinDonos wrote:Heheh

I guess we agree that the Griz signing this guy will greatly benifit our blitzing LB's.

i was hoping this wasn't going to happen. i think that it is common knowledge that if we'd gotten this guy, or any other guy that left montana and montana state open, then the griz would tell us they didn't want him, or that he wasn't good enough for there program. sorry to throw them all in the same boat, but i have been reading comments like these since the espn.com days! let's be the bigger guys, and just accept it for what it is. i was even one of the guys from the very beginning that said i was sick of hearing about him, and that from what i saw and heard, he wasn't that great. but that doesn't mean he can't be very good for one year. we are gonna feel like asses if this guy turns it on, and tears up the sky next year. i like watching the griz fans sound like hypocrites, and eating their words. i hope i don't have to watch my fellow bobcats do the same!

You guys are something else. The guy decides to play for the Griz, and you all make it sound like the guy could not play for Rocky Mountain. And everyone makes it sound like he is a primadonna, since he did not commit in a day when Kramer pushed the issue. Time will tell if he makes a difference on the field, but either school would have been happy to improve the talent at the QB position. As for the comment about being the starter, all that was said is that going into Spring drills he would be #1 on the depth chart, nothing beyond Spring, so everyone will get a chance.

grizindahouse wrote:You guys are something else. The guy decides to play for the Griz, and you all make it sound like the guy could not play for Rocky Mountain. And everyone makes it sound like he is a primadonna, since he did not commit in a day when Kramer pushed the issue. Time will tell if he makes a difference on the field, but either school would have been happy to improve the talent at the QB position. As for the comment about being the starter, all that was said is that going into Spring drills he would be #1 on the depth chart, nothing beyond Spring, so everyone will get a chance.

Actually there were quite a few people on this board that DID NOT want MSU to go after Swogger. I was one of them. I want a more mobile type QB with a decent arm to go along with a power running game and a good defense. I think we will end up having all 3 next year. I think it was too much of a risk to have him come in for just one year and pick up the offense etc. If he played at Washington State he for sure has some talent, but how quickly he picks up the offense etc. remains to be seen. The fact is, the Griz dont' have any RAC type receivers so they are going to have to dink and dunk again I think. It should be interesting next year. Just wait though, if he comes in and loses a few games for them (slow/sacked/fumbles etc.) then they will be all over Hauck. I wish the kid the best, but I'm glad we didn't go that route to be honest.

whitetrashgriz wrote:

GavinDonos wrote:Heheh

I guess we agree that the Griz signing this guy will greatly benifit our blitzing LB's.

i was hoping this wasn't going to happen. i think that it is common knowledge that if we'd gotten this guy, or any other guy that left montana and montana state open, then the griz would tell us they didn't want him, or that he wasn't good enough for there program. sorry to throw them all in the same boat, but i have been reading comments like these since the espn.com days! let's be the bigger guys, and just accept it for what it is. i was even one of the guys from the very beginning that said i was sick of hearing about him, and that from what i saw and heard, he wasn't that great. but that doesn't mean he can't be very good for one year. we are gonna feel like asses if this guy turns it on, and tears up the sky next year. i like watching the griz fans sound like hypocrites, and eating their words. i hope i don't have to watch my fellow bobcats do the same!

Why should I be afraid to say that I didn't want this guy to come to MSU? Heck there are some Griz fans who aren't exactly thrilled that he signed with UM.

Ever since he gave MSU an stern warning, saying that our signing deadline "isn't very smart" on our part, I could have cared less where he went. I applaud Kramer for sticking to that deadline and not getting caught up in the soap opera that ensued.

It's clear that Swogger wasn't interested in going somewhere where he would have to fight for the job, he as much as says that. And I found it interesting how he kept playing the waiting game while giving several interviews per week during this whole process. I wonder if this kid likes attention? We don't need that attitude on our club. We've got our guy Carpenter and some new blood in Rolo and Desin. A situation like Swogger's would do nothing but ​ the process.

This isn't sour grapes on my part, and I'm not gonna put on a show and pat the efriz gasbags on the back when my true feelings are absolutely legitimate.

Maybe I wish he woulda went to YSU instead of either UM or another 'Sky school such as EWU, but that doesn't mean I wish he was a 'Cat. Sorry, no apologies here.

CARDIAC_CATS wrote:And Baby Hauck has already named him the spring drill starter. Gotta love that if your Berquist or Washington I hope he starts for them, is a bust and they burn another year of Berquist's/Washington/Stapp's eligibility

I have to admit that doesn't look good... You have a sophomore returning who started last season and you take the team away from him. Usually your starter from the year before has the position to lose, but not when Bobby is at the helm (must be part of his “great” recruiting tactics- hope Selle loves his chances as starting as a true freshman now).

I have to admit that I really wanted this guy to go to a non-Big Sky school, just incase he turns out to be a stud. Of course he was the back up for a team that won only four games in 2005 (those wins included Grambling and Idaho).

One thing about him going to the Cats is, he wasn't able to see what your new QB is capable of. Hauck and Kramer probably said the same thing, you can compete for the starting job. He doesn't know what he's competing against in Bozeman. All he has seen is Lulay. He can look at our game tape, watch our starting QB's, and see we had something like 1 passing TD in the last 5 games and know it wouldn't be too difficult to walk in and take over.

grizindahouse wrote:You guys are something else. The guy decides to play for the Griz, and you all make it sound like the guy could not play for Rocky Mountain. And everyone makes it sound like he is a primadonna, since he did not commit in a day when Kramer pushed the issue. Time will tell if he makes a difference on the field, but either school would have been happy to improve the talent at the QB position. As for the comment about being the starter, all that was said is that going into Spring drills he would be #1 on the depth chart, nothing beyond Spring, so everyone will get a chance.

See my post above.
Blanket generalizations do not help make your case.

I'll say it again. I think he is a good pick up for the Griz.

Now....since you mentioned Rocky Mountain - what do you think the chances are that Bergquist and/or Washington stick around UM. I don't know the Carroll backup QB situation, but Emmert is graduating, and if you really want to win a national title, Carroll probably has your best odds.

GavinDonos wrote:

whitetrashgriz wrote:

GavinDonos wrote:Heheh

I guess we agree that the Griz signing this guy will greatly benifit our blitzing LB's.

i was hoping this wasn't going to happen. i think that it is common knowledge that if we'd gotten this guy, or any other guy that left montana and montana state open, then the griz would tell us they didn't want him, or that he wasn't good enough for there program. sorry to throw them all in the same boat, but i have been reading comments like these since the espn.com days! let's be the bigger guys, and just accept it for what it is. i was even one of the guys from the very beginning that said i was sick of hearing about him, and that from what i saw and heard, he wasn't that great. but that doesn't mean he can't be very good for one year. we are gonna feel like asses if this guy turns it on, and tears up the sky next year. i like watching the griz fans sound like hypocrites, and eating their words. i hope i don't have to watch my fellow bobcats do the same!

Why should I be afraid to say that I didn't want this guy to come to MSU? Heck there are some Griz fans who aren't exactly thrilled that he signed with UM.

Ever since he gave MSU an stern warning, saying that our signing deadline "isn't very smart" on our part, I could have cared less where he went. I applaud Kramer for sticking to that deadline and not getting caught up in the soap opera that ensued.

It's clear that Swogger wasn't interested in going somewhere where he would have to fight for the job, he as much as says that. And I found it interesting how he kept playing the waiting game while giving several interviews per week during this whole process. I wonder if this kid likes attention? We don't need that attitude on our club. We've got our guy Carpenter and some new blood in Rolo and Desin. A situation like Swogger's would do nothing but ​ the process.

This isn't sour grapes on my part, and I'm not gonna put on a show and pat the efriz gasbags on the back when my true feelings are absolutely legitimate.

Maybe I wish he woulda went to YSU instead of either UM or another 'Sky school such as EWU, but that doesn't mean I wish he was a 'Cat. Sorry, no apologies here.

first, i never said anyone had to apologize for anything. but i know cat fans. we are not like some of the griz. even those os us, myself included that didn't think he'd be a good fit for the cats, i think would embrace him if he did come here. if we could accept tyler thomas, and try to convine ourselves and others that he was a good qb, i don't see why we wouldn't do the same with swogger. but because we didn't get him, i just dont see any need to rag on him until we see what he does. just my opinion man! you can talk crap about him until kickoff for all i care! i will say that unless someone on this board actually knows him, i think some of the comments are unnecessary. maybe he wasn't playing a "waiting game." maybe he doesn't "like attention". and maybe he doesn't have "an attitude." we dont no anything about this guy. he has himself, a wife, family, and friends all to consider. maybe he's just as glad as everyone that this thing is over. all i was saying is that some of the posts sounded very "grizish", with the he sucks, our lb's will kill him, he's got an attitude, he likes attention smack!

I'm not going to make apologies either. I am glad that he didn't go to MSU. I am a huge Carpenter fan. I saw what Carpenter did in the Spring '05 game and was very impressed.

I am not saying that anyone has to apologize because he did not decide to atend MSU, but for a MAJORITY of you to call him a primadonna, and already judge his skills is what just slays me. There are many people that did want him at each school, and many that did not.

HelenaCat, I was already under the assumption, well before Swogger, that Washington would not be back with the program next year. I had heard that he was already looking to leave, because he had determined that he would not be ahead of Cole or Clint when Spring drills started.

grizindahouse wrote:..for a MAJORITY of you to call him a primadonna, and already judge his skills is what just slays me.

First impressions are a bitch, I guess...

All I know is that although his career stats are FAR from remarkable, Swogger has left one school because he wasn't the starter, and appears to have chosen another because the spot was handed to him off the bat. Great kid, good QB, but not what we need at MSU right now, IMHO. I agree that it sure helps the Griz situation, tho; so in that case I guess I can congratulate you guys and say that with the way things worked out, everyone from Bobby to Swoggy to 'lil ol me ought to be happy.

grizindahouse wrote:I am not saying that anyone has to apologize because he did not decide to atend MSU, but for a MAJORITY of you to call him a primadonna, and already judge his skills is what just slays me. There are many people that did want him at each school, and many that did not.

HelenaCat, I was already under the assumption, well before Swogger, that Washington would not be back with the program next year. I had heard that he was already looking to leave, because he had determined that he would not be ahead of Cole or Clint when Spring drills started.

But what if these same people were saying this even when MSU was supposedly in the running for him? Now that he is signed with the Griz, are they supposed to change their opinions and bow down to him? I know I didn't want him to go to MSU either. I didn't want him at UM just in case he turned out to be really good, but I was definitely turned off by what I was reading during the all-too-public recruiting process, and I was glad that MSU was out of the picture.