tdub wrote: ↑Thu Jan 19, 2023 10:04 am
ThoughtUKnew14 wrote: ↑Thu Jan 19, 2023 9:59 am
ND0479 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 18, 2023 8:21 pm
AFCAT wrote: ↑Wed Jan 18, 2023 7:43 pm
VimSince03 wrote: ↑Wed Jan 18, 2023 7:38 pm
Transfer from UW.
And a former 4 star. I know how you love those ratings.
4 star talent level with a -2 star commitment level. I’m sure he has his reasons but you have to raise an eyebrow at 3rd school in 3 years.
Anyways, welcome to Bozeman and hope he finds what he’s looking for with the Cats!
Exactly! Why not build with what we have?!?! I bet this makes him an automatic starter since he is coming from FBS level just like they have done with the others. I don’t like the feel of this…
Did you feel the same way about Bryce Sterk?
Yeah the narratives coming out of some Bobcatnation accounts these past few weeks have been something else. WR was an area we desperately needed starter and depth additions through transfers that would be able to compete immediately. We lost two starters and one contributor (Alston, Patterson, and Steel) with Alston and Patterson being major parts of our offensive production (Alston for his blocking and Patterson for his playmaking ability). Getting Clevan Thomas back was one of our best recruiting wins so far this year in my opinion. So who do we have coming back where everyone is screaming to "build with what we have":
True Freshman last fall who redshirted
Christian Anaya - played late in a few games but coaches correctly redshirted him as he clearly wasn't ready physically to be a major contributor on the outside fresh out of high school. However, has a high talent ceiling and should push for rotation time next fall. The spring will be big for him.
Dylan Snyder - redshirted but coaches liked what they saw out of him this fall as a scout receiver. Was very raw as a receiver out of high school but really physical after the catch and has no issues blocking which is why Dylan may be a sneaky contributor next year if he keeps progressing as an overall receiver. Will likely play a role on special teams next fall.
Noah Smith - was a grayshirt during that COVID year so technically was in his second year last fall but still redshirted. Was a higher profile recruit out of Texas a few years ago and is one of our tallest receivers. Very intrigued by how he looks this spring because if he looks good Noah is a kid who can push the starters due to his talent. But if he looks like "just a guy" entering his 3rd year (2nd football year) then the development has hit a snag.
Zachary Dodson-Green - a PWO late last year who redshirted last fall. However, he and Dylan Snyder drew praise from Udy and Vigen for their scout team performances last fall. Zachary is a slight frame kid so just needs to keep developing but you always have to track scout team standouts because it means they are pushing our varsity guys to be better in some way.
Others who saw minutes last fall
Aidan Garrigan - you won't find a bigger fan of Aidan Garrigan than me (with maybe the exception of his family). I thought he popped last spring but just wasn't quite physical enough or athletic enough to beat out guys like Ravi, Clevan, Willie, and Taco. Caught his first touchdown against Cal Poly and played special teams all year. Quite frankly I think Vigen and Co. brought in Alexander Jr. to push guys like Aidan and Christian because they know their potential is high and have chances to be starters next year. He'll be about 6'3, 205 lbs., already runs great routes, has good hands, and will get his nose dirty in the run game. Sounds like a WR fit to me in MSU's system!
Malik Mullins - got hurt early last fall and didn't come back until late in the year. He's a long receiver but you can tell he needs more development in route running and playing the position at a higher level. They brought him in to develop and eventually compete so this spring will also be huge for Malik to show he belongs with that outside receiver bunch.
And that's really it because Tayvian Williams and Marquis Johnson are RBs who can also line up in the slot and we already know how Johnson can factor into changing a game. Clevan and Taco are known commodities and will be two of our starters next year. So what does this depth chart look like? Here is my best guess heading into spring:
X Receiver
Aidan Garrigan - 6'3", 205 lbs. (RSo.)
/Lonyatta Alexander Jr. - 6'1", 200 lbs. (Jr.)
Malik Mullins - 6'3", 190 lbs. (So.)
H Receiver
Taco Dowler - 5'9", 170 lbs. (So.)
Marqui Johnson - 5'8", 165 lbs. (Jr.)
Z Receiver
Clevan Thomas - 5'11", 195 lbs. (GSr.)
Ty McCulloch - 6'1", 180 lbs. (Sr.)
/Christian Anaya - 6'1", 175 lbs. (RFr.)
Also on the roster:
Garrett Walchli - 5'8", 180 lbs. (Jr.) - Good luck to him trying to beat out Taco or Marquis plus Clevan
Dylan Snyder - 6'2", 190 lbs. (RFr.) - Spring will show us where he's at in development but should play special teams
Noah Smith - 6'3", 190 lbs. (RFr.) - Needs to start showing what everyone saw on film his senior season in high school
Zachary Dodson-Green - 6'1", 170 lbs. (RFr.) - Needs to get bigger but opened eyes as a scout teamer last fall
Javonte King - 6'4", 200 lbs. (Fr.) - He's a huge but tall doesn't always translate to production right away in college...still excited about him
Jacob Trimble - 6'0", 185 lbs. (Fr.) - I mean we all know Jacob is going to be the next Kevin Kassis right?