Save the planet, quit drinking bottled water.

[Stevicat]

February 14, 2006]


Thirst for bottled water is pouring resources down drain

(The Herald Via Thomson Dialog NewsEdge)EVEN with the recent rise in crude oil prices, it can still cost more to buy bottled water in the United States than to pump the same volume of gasoline into your car's tank.

At the inflated prices charged for bottled water in restaurants in Britain, the same conclusion is readily drawn from drinking bottled water while dining out here.

But such perverse economic logic is not stopping Americans, or the rest of us, drinking more and more expensive water from the bottle, rather than the much cheaper version available from any tap. We may rail against higher petrol prices, but we seem intent on drinking bottled water at almost any price.

US consumption of bottled water hit 25.8 billion litres in 2004, a rise of 49percent on demand five years earlier. The United States still dominates global consumption, estimated at some 154 billion litres in 2004. However the thirst for bottled water is rising even faster globally, up by 57percent since 1999.

This is not just a lifestyle or designer phenomenon. The next three countries behind the US in the global top 10 are Mexico, China and Brazil. And while four European states - Italy, Germany, France and Spain - are also among the world's biggest bottled water consumers, the eighth and 10th spots go to Indonesia and India respectively.

All, developed and developing countries alike, are showing strong consumption growth year-on-year. So is the UK, as the most casual observation in supermarkets, convenience stores, filling stations, let alone restaurants here quickly demonstrates. But we are still well off the global pace in this particular race to drink water in the most expensive form possible.

In per-capita terms, Italy leads the field. The average Italian was drinking nearly 184 litres of bottled water in 2004. The average Briton managed just 33 litres.

The top 15 in the per-capita consumption league includes 10 European Union states (including the Czech Republic), the US and Mexico, and three middle eastern countries, the United Arab Emirates, Lebanon and Saudi Arabia.

Indeed, one Finnish company shipped 1.4 million bottles of local tap water to Saudi Arabia from its Helsinki bottling plant in 2004. And one of the most fashionable brands on sale in the US comes all the way from Fiji. We think nothing of drinking water that originates in Italy or France.

But to reach us in bottled form, this global trade in water is imposing significant pressure on the earth's resources. As a new report from the Washington-based Earth Policy Institute puts it, it is tantamount to "pouring resources down the drain".

The report, by Emily Arnold, argues that, in the industrialised world, "bottled water is often no healthier than tap water" despite the fact that it can cost up to 10,000 times more. But to package and distribute it - nearly a quarter of all those 154 billion litres cross a national border before being drunk, apparently - consumes vast quantities of energy and generates a lot of unnecessary waste.

Most containers are made from the form of plastic known as PET, polyethylene terephthalate, patented way back in 1941 and favoured for its barrier qualities when faced with oxygen or carbon dioxide. PET is processed from crude oil.

According to Arnold, making enough bottles to satisfy US demand each year could, in effect, keep another 100,000 cars on American roads over the same period.

The big disposal problem with PET is that burning it generates chlorine and heavy metals, while putting it to landfill means leaving it for 1000 years or more to biodegrade.

Recycling increasingly means using even more energy to ship large quantities of this particular plastic back to countries like China and India for processing.

But that, argues Emily Arnold, is not the only strain this growing trade puts on our environment. Extraction of water for bottling is causing local water shortages from India all the way to the Great Lakes and Texas.

Progressive climate change is arguably beginning to disrupt normal water supplies in more and more parts of the world. After a very dry January, water utilities in many parts of the UK are reporting below-average reserves in their reservoirs and warning of restrictions to come this summer if it does not rain soon.

But what of the rising consumption of bottled water in poorer parts of the globe. Mexico stands second in that global league table, remember, and Indonesia and India are both in the top 10. Isn't that not providing clean water to people who might not otherwise have any access to it?

Arnold claims bottled water isn't even going to solve the problems of around 1.1 billion people living today who have no access to a secure, clean water supply. She points out that the UN millennium development goal for environmental sustainability calls for a halving of the proportion of people lacking access to safe drinking water by 2015.

The price tag is a doubling of the [dollars]15bn ([GBP]8.5bn) a year the world currently spends on water supply and sanitation. "While this amount may seem large, " she writes, "it pales in comparison to the estimated [dollars]100bn spent each year on bottled water."

[grizzh8r]

Buy a tap water filter and a Nalgene bottle if you can't stand water with chlorine. It still baffles me that people will pay money for water...

[ChiOCat]

Are water bottles worse for the environment than soda bottles?

At least water doesn't contribute to our growing waistlines.

[CelticCat]

I'll never understand why people buy bottled water. It is a fad that makes people feel better about themselves.

I've drank tap water my whole life and I rarely get sick. I just started using a filter, it might taste a smidge better, but for 15 bucks was a much better investment than 1.50-6 bucks worth of bottled water per day.

I try not to buy bottled pop because it is more expensive, but I do now and again. It is expensive and a hassle to be able to drink pop from your home that you didn't purchase. You'd have to buy a dispenser.

I also hate ketchup packets, what a waste of resources that is.

[SonomaCat]

On the bottled water issue ... I have to agree with everybody ... in small parts.

I don't drink bottled water at home (filter in the fridge works great ... and SF has some of the best tap water in the country, fortunately), and I think some people do go overboard in thinking that tap water is akin to poison, when in most places tap water is perfectly fine.

At work, the bottled water is free, so I take it (and recycle the bottles, of course). The days of water fountains in office buildings is long gone, so this is essentially our only option for water.

Around town or on the road, buying a bottle of water is also about the only option. There's just never a water fountain when you need one.

So I carry a water bottle around a lot, but it's not because it's hip or because I want to look cool or feel better about myself ... it's more because I get thirsty sometimes ... and those water fountains that I always used in grade school and high school (and partway through college) just aren't all that handy anymore.

[CelticCat]

On the bottled water issue ... I have to agree with everybody ... in small parts.

I don't drink bottled water at home (filter in the fridge works great ... and SF has some of the best tap water in the country, fortunately), and I think some people do go overboard in thinking that tap water is akin to poison, when in most places tap water is perfectly fine.

At work, the bottled water is free, so I take it (and recycle the bottles, of course). The days of water fountains in office buildings is long gone, so this is essentially our only option for water.

Around town or on the road, buying a bottle of water is also about the only option. There's just never a water fountain when you need one.

So I carry a water bottle around a lot, but it's not because it's hip or because I want to look cool or feel better about myself ... it's more because I get thirsty sometimes ... and those water fountains that I always used in grade school and high school (and partway through college) just aren't all that handy anymore.

Nalgene. Mine has a Bobcat on it.

[Grizlaw]

I drink tap water, filtered through one of those Brita water filter pitchers that you can keep in your fridge, and it tastes great.

However, I do have to say one thing about bottled water -- growing up in Butte, most families I knew had one of those little water dispensers in their kitchens, because in the mid-80s, Butte water was contaminated (as in there were actual public warnings to either boil your water or use bottled water, not as in it just didn't taste good). So I got used to bottled water from the water dispenser. I don't think the quality of bottled water is any better, but the temperature is -- no matter where you are, tap water will never be as cold as the water that comes out of those dispensers, and once you're used to drinking really cold water, the cold water that comes out of your tap never tastes as good (unless it's refrigerated, of course...)

[SonomaCat]

On the bottled water issue ... I have to agree with everybody ... in small parts.

I don't drink bottled water at home (filter in the fridge works great ... and SF has some of the best tap water in the country, fortunately), and I think some people do go overboard in thinking that tap water is akin to poison, when in most places tap water is perfectly fine.

At work, the bottled water is free, so I take it (and recycle the bottles, of course). The days of water fountains in office buildings is long gone, so this is essentially our only option for water.

Around town or on the road, buying a bottle of water is also about the only option. There's just never a water fountain when you need one.

So I carry a water bottle around a lot, but it's not because it's hip or because I want to look cool or feel better about myself ... it's more because I get thirsty sometimes ... and those water fountains that I always used in grade school and high school (and partway through college) just aren't all that handy anymore.

Nalgene. Mine has a Bobcat on it.

Funny ... I think I saw one of those in the MSU bookstore a couple weeks ago when I was in town, and said something aloud about getting one. And then my fiance asked me why I would need one ... and I didn't have a good answer ... so I passed on buying it. But something about it was calling out to me "Buy me, buy me!"

[ChiOCat]

On the bottled water issue ... I have to agree with everybody ... in small parts.

I don't drink bottled water at home (filter in the fridge works great ... and SF has some of the best tap water in the country, fortunately), and I think some people do go overboard in thinking that tap water is akin to poison, when in most places tap water is perfectly fine.

At work, the bottled water is free, so I take it (and recycle the bottles, of course). The days of water fountains in office buildings is long gone, so this is essentially our only option for water.

Around town or on the road, buying a bottle of water is also about the only option. There's just never a water fountain when you need one.

So I carry a water bottle around a lot, but it's not because it's hip or because I want to look cool or feel better about myself ... it's more because I get thirsty sometimes ... and those water fountains that I always used in grade school and high school (and partway through college) just aren't all that handy anymore.

Nalgene. Mine has a Bobcat on it.

Diapers, kids, keys....there's no chance I'm going to remember a Nalgene bottle on my way out the door too. I usually only buy bottles when driving long distances, so I don't feel too bad.

And Richland county is known for their great water We're one of the few families I know around here that do drink the tap water.